The German-American Shepherd Split

By Martin Wahl

 

Pfeffer.jpg (4833 bytes)
Pfeffer von Bern

Until the outbreak of the second World War, German Shepherds in America where identical to the German Shepherds in Germany. The last dog imported from Germany before the war to have a major impact on the GSD in America was "Pfeffer von Bern". He became the US Grand Victor in 1937, and in the same year went back to Germany to become the German National Show Sieger, then became the US Grand Victor again in 1938. By producing about 47 Am Chs he became the first ROM in 1952 and did dominate the US bloodlines throughout the 1940s.

During the second world war the GSD in America, cut off from its German roots, and quite possibly subject to some German bashing made fashionable by the war, started to develop its own appearance, mostly through very close line breeding, but in many instances also through repeated inbreeding. After the end of the war, some American breeders recognized the need to get back to the original working shepherd and spent good money on imported GSD’s from Germany, but a new trend had started. American judges and breeders had developed "a taste" for their own, uniquely "American" style German Shepherd, featuring a more "refined look", and a lot more hind leg angulation to get that "unreal floating side gaite".

One drastic example of the widening split between German and American bloodlines in the 1960s is "Bodo vom Lierberg SchH3, FH". He was the 1967 German, Dutch and Belgian Sieger (Grand Victor), was sold to America, but didn’t make US Grand victor and ended up contributing very little to the breed. His brother, "Bernd vom Lierberg Sch3, FH" being as similar to Bodo in look and temperament as only a twin brother can be, remained in Germany and became THE most famous working dog ever since. They where the last all-in-one "universal" working and show dogs. Any real working Shepherd breeder in the world would give just about anything to have the name Bernd or Bodo vom Lierberg in his/her pedigree. Some breeders even use "sound-alike" kennel names to cash-in on the fame of that name.

During the 1950s and 60s, only about half of the US Grand Victors were German imports, the last one being "Arno von der Kurpfalzhalle" in 1969. Since then, the American Shepherd has gone its own way entirely, and today, no German import would have a chance of winning anything in an American show ring. The "American" Shepherd has become a pure object of beauty, to be looked at through a window. Its ability to be useful, reliable, well tempered and healthy, in fact, every thing the German Shepherd originally became famous for, has been sacrificed for that "floating side gait" during the last 30 years of AKC style inbreeding. There is absolutely no resemblance left between those two separate breeds of Shepherds, except the name.

The majority of American breeders are aware of the extreme difference in the quality of the American Shepherds they breed, and are attempting to cover up this fact by using German sounding kennel names, in the hope of fooling the public.

Bodo_l.jpg (9945 bytes)
Bodo vom Lierberg SchH3

Bernd_l.jpg (10643 bytes)
Bernd vom Lierberg SchH3

AmChgrey.jpg (10220 bytes)
American & Select Canadian
Ch. Bakervue's Breman of Cedar

For more information, see: recommended books on German Shepherds

  Return Home

 

Copyright 2001 Martin Wahl, Real GSD.  RealGSD1@netscape.net.  All rights reserved.   Please view his site Real GSD.